Uncategorized


  • PPP/PFI Profits

    Excessive profits obtained by PPP companies and banks is again in the news. The first evidence on the scale of excessive PFI profits and the growth the secondary market was detailed in *Global Auction of Public Assets* by Dexter Whitfield and followed by a more detailed research in *The £10bn Sale of Shares in PPP…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • The payments-by-result road to marketisation, Dexter Whitfield

    “‘Payment by results’ has become the new performance management mantra. It is intended to incentivise contractors, with payment conditional on the completion of agreed outputs or outcomes. There are currently two such payment and reward models: the social impact bond mechanism and phased incentive payments.” This article examines the implications of this approach, the growth…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Recent events

    In February Dexter Whitfield gave lectures at the University of Sheffield (Department of Sociological Studies), Queens University, Belfast (School of Management), given evidence to the Public Accounts Committee, Western Australia State Government, and a presentation to the Canadian Union of Public Employees bi-annual research meeting.

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Barnet’s high-risk strategy for customer and support services

    An assessment of a business case update for the customer and support services outsourcing highlights the London Borough of Barnet’s approach – ignore real risks, miscalculate client costs, exaggerate savings, claim non-financial benefits that cannot be substantiated, inadequate equalities assessments and ignore the high failure rate PPP strategic partnership track record. The Council’s refusal to…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Plan B and Beyond

    A critical assessment of Compass’s Plan B that reveals its shortcomings and need for a more radical and comprehensive socialist alternative, by Dexter Whitfield, Red Pepper Issue 182, Feb/Mar 2012.

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Transfer of Housing Service to Barnet Homes

    A detailed analysis of the proposed transfer of the London Borough of Barnet’s Housing Service to Barnet Homes, the ALMO established in 2004. The Council truncated the options appraisal and business case into one process, limiting the options and pre-selecting the preferred option, and has led to a further deterioration in the quality of options…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Local Authority Trading Company (LATC) for Adult and Housing Services

    The London Borough of Barnet plans to establish a LATC that requires Adult Services to generate up to 90% of the £0.7m annual profit. Yet the financial viability of Barnet Group Ltd (Yours Choice Barnet and Barnet Homes) is highly questionable. This report details the flawed appraisal process, the reasons for financial instability, governance and…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • 2012

    2012 news and events from the European Services Strategy Unit.

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • New edition of PPP Database on Strategic Partnerships

    The Database now covers 48 strategic partnerships and has been expanded with more analysis of operational contracts, a new Strategic Partnership Performance Ratio, and new tables on community trusts in strategic partnerships and contractor performance.

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.


  • Compelling Evidence Against a Strategic Partnership

    Analysis of the London Borough of Tower Hamlets approach to procurement of a strategic partnership for ICT and corporate services, employing 615 staff. Reveals that there was no evidence of an options or business case prior to the start of procurement. Highlights the limitations of strategic partnerships and the potential impact on the local economy…

    Published on 3rd May 2012. Last updated 3rd June 2017.